Início/Recursos/Conhecimento/Testing&Analysis/Lithium Plating Detection: Three-Electrode Testing Guide

Lithium Plating Detection: Three-Electrode Testing Guide

Canrd November 5, 2026 285

Lithium plating is one of the most critical failure modes for graphite lithium-ion batteries, especially under fast-charging conditions. Many battery R&D engineers rely on three-electrode cell testing and monitor anode potential to judge lithium plating.

A common lab puzzle: the three-electrode reading shows negative anode potential at end-of-charge, but cell disassembly finds no visible lithium deposits. In other tests, potential bounces back positive after relaxation, yet obvious lithium plating appears after opening the cell.

This guide breaks down how to correctly interpret three-electrode test data, avoid measurement artifacts, and build a reliable workflow for lithium plating diagnosis.

What Is Negative Anode Potential?

During normal charging, lithium ions intercalate into graphite layers. Lithium plating is a competing side reaction: lithium metal deposits on graphite surface instead of inserting into the carbon lattice.

Thermodynamically, plating becomes favorable when the interfacial anode potential drops below 0 V vs Li/Li⁺. However, a single negative reading cannot directly confirm metallic lithium deposition.

The measured value may differ from the local interfacial potential relevant to lithium plating. It is affected by:

  1. Electrolyte potential difference (includes ohmic and concentration-gradient contributions)
  2. Reference electrode position and geometry
  3. Electrode heterogeneity and local current density
  4. Instrument measurement noise

A negative anode potential is a risk warning, not final proof of lithium plating.

Why Negative Potential May Show No Visible Lithium Plating

There are multiple possible explanations for this conflicting observation.

Observation Possible explanations Recommended checks
Negative reading without visible deposits Reference artefacts, small or localized deposits, or redistribution before inspection Validate the reference and measurement system; control inspection timing
Deposits observed without a clear relaxation feature Limited signal sensitivity, deposit isolation, protocol effects or uncertain deposit identity Review raw data, matched baselines and lithium-specific evidence
Suspected localized plating not reflected in the reference signal Spatial sensitivity limitations or configuration-dependent measurement error Validate the reference design and compare locations using matched cells

Visual post-mortem inspection has detection limits. Minor lithium plating can already occur before you can see metallic lithium on the electrode.

Why Positive Resting Potential Does Not Rule Out Lithium Plating

After charging stops, polarization fades and lithium redistributes inside the electrode. The anode potential may relax toward a positive value, even if lithium metal plated during charging.

Part of plated lithium is reversible and re-intercalates into graphite. Other fraction becomes electrically isolated “dead lithium” and cannot recover. The final resting potential is not a fixed value such as 80 mV or 85 mV. It changes with lithiation state, temperature, relaxation time and reference setup.

Detect Lithium Plating Using Voltage Relaxation & dV/dt Curve

The potential relaxation process provides additional diagnostic information beyond a single end-of-charge or resting-potential reading. Its interpretation requires matched baselines and independent validation.

Note: Full-cell voltage reflects both electrode potentials. When the positive-electrode contribution is relatively small, an anode-related relaxation feature may appear with the opposite sign in the full-cell response. The curves are not necessarily exact mirror images.

  • Raw relaxation curve (V vs Time)

A cell without detectable plating may show a relatively smooth relaxation response, although the curve need not follow a single exponential. Recoverable plated lithium can introduce a shoulder, a low-slope region or an inflection. A reproducible derivative feature that differs from a matched baseline may support a plating diagnosis, but neither its presence nor its absence is universally conclusive.

  • First derivative curve dV/dt

Calculate the slope change of relaxation data:

During rest, electrochemically connected lithium deposits can be oxidized while lithium ions intercalate into graphite. These coupled reactions may create a mixed-potential region and modify the relaxation profile. A derivative extremum can indicate a transition in this response, but does not independently establish the endpoint of stripping or the complete removal of metallic lithium.

Important notes:

  1. Differentiation amplifies noise, so raw data quality and smoothing settings must be documented.
  2. Always compare with matched baseline cells under identical test conditions.

Reference Electrode Placement: Center vs Edge

A centrally positioned reference does not automatically measure the electrode-average potential. Its reading depends on the local electrolyte potential field, reference geometry and cell configuration. Neither central nor edge placement is universally optimal; the arrangement must be validated for the intended measurement.

Regions near tabs or edges can be selected as candidate locations when investigating suspected localized plating, but this is not a universal solution.

How to Handle iR Compensation

The measured anode potential formula:

Where:

E_neg,int represents the relevant interfacial electrode potential.

Δφ_electrolyte represents the electrolyte potential difference between measurement locations. This term can include both ohmic and concentration-related contributions.

ε_ref represents reference offset or drift.

ε_instrument represents measurement error.

The signs depend on the wiring and definitions used. The interfacial term itself contains equilibrium and polarization contributions.

  • Current interruption / current-step method can estimate a fast voltage-response component; it does not remove all reference-related or concentration-related errors.
  • Do not blindly enable auto iR compensation. Do not adjust correction values only to force negative readings to become positive.
  • Always report raw potential data and corrected results separately, with full documentation of your correction method.

Practical Three-Electrode Lithium Plating Evaluation Workflow

Canrd provides custom three-electrode cells, electrode fabrication and electrochemical testing services for battery R&D. This staged workflow helps avoid false positive/negative plating judgement.

  1. Define your research objective Select variables to compare: charging C-rate, temperature, electrode loading, electrolyte formulations or graphite materials. Keep other parameters fixed.
  2. Build baseline cells Record cell capacity, formation history, electrode balance and reference preparation. Check for measurable changes introduced by the reference. Matched capacity and voltage response cannot prove the absence of local disturbance.
  3. Record full charge relaxation data Capture current, full-cell voltage, individual electrode potentials and temperature continuously. End-of-charge potential is a risk indicator; relaxation curve adds complementary diagnostic information.
  4. Compare relaxation curves and dV/dt derivative against baselines Check reproducible curve features, avoid relying on one single test run.
  5. Cross-validate with independent evidence Combine electrochemical signals with post-mortem checks: disassembly imaging, SEM (for surface morphology only; conventional EDS cannot reliably identify metallic lithium), coulombic efficiency tracking or validated lithium-specific chemical analysis.No single indirect electrochemical indicator is universally conclusive.
  6. Control disassembly timing Use matched cells with different resting durations. Perform cell opening inside an inert atmosphere, as sample exposure can modify lithium deposits.

Common Test Problems & Possible Explanations

  1. Artificially negative potential reading, no lithium plating after disassembly Possible explanations: Reference artefacts, small localized deposits or lithium redistribution before inspection. Recommended checks: Validate reference and measurement system; control the time gap between charge and disassembly.
  2. Visible deposits observed, no obvious relaxation feature Possible explanations: Limited signal sensitivity, electrically isolated deposits, test protocol effects or uncertainty whether observed deposits are metallic lithium. Recommended checks: Review raw data, matched baselines and validated lithium-specific characterization.
  3. Suspected localized plating cannot be captured by reference measurement Possible explanations: Spatial sensitivity limitations or geometry-dependent measurement bias. Recommended checks: Validate reference design and run parallel tests at alternative positions with replicate matched cells.

FAQs

Q: Can three-electrode testing detect lithium plating reliably?

A: It provides powerful evidence of plating risk. Reliability depends on validated reference setup, accurate potential measurement and cross-check with independent characterization.

Q: Should I judge plating by end-of-charge potential or resting equilibrium potential?

A: Neither single point works. You need the complete dynamic relaxation profile. End-of-charge potential shows charging risk; relaxation reveals what happens to lithium after charge stops.

Q: Does a relaxation plateau confirm lithium plating?

A: A reproducible plateau supported by baseline comparison and extra evidence strongly indicates plating. Absence of plateau cannot rule out small, localized or electrically isolated lithium deposits.

Q: Is edge reference always more accurate?

A: Not always. Reference position must be validated for your specific cell geometry. Changing reference position alters measurement error and spatial sensitivity.

Conclusion

For graphite cell R&D, negative anode potential alone cannot confirm lithium plating. Useful diagnostic tools include the full voltage relaxation curve and its dV/dt derivative.

Measurement artifacts including uncompensated electrolyte potential differences and improperly placed reference electrodes easily create misleading results. Always combine three-electrode electrochemical data, baseline comparison and post-mortem validation to make robust lithium plating assessment.

Canrd supports battery research teams with custom three-electrode cell fabrication, electrode preparation and failure analysis. For project consultation, share your cell chemistry, electrode specs, charging profile and target test requirements.